lundi 24 avril 2017

104- Natural vs synthetic -4- About the production of natural pyrethrins


Following my previous article in this series on pyrethrins and pyrethroids (, I received a question, on April 5, on the French version "Hello, to produce natural pyrethrins, it is advisable to grow flowers of pyrethras. More and more pyrethras, since there is more and more organic farming. Do you know if the cultivation of these pyrethrum flowers is done in organic farming? "
My answer was "I dare not even think that pyrethrum fields for the production of organic pesticides can be grown with synthetic pesticides. But, is there any control? I don't know. "

But Wackes Seppi, known to the francophone agricultural community for his blog ( abundantly provided and critical, gives me a link in French (, with the comment "You will fall on your ass! "

And I fell on my ass!!!

Erwan Seznec is a freelance French journalist, known for his critical stances, often going against social and political correctness.
In October 2016, he published on his blog the following article, which I reproduce in full, as usual.

"How organic outsources conventional pesticides to poor countries- 12/10/16

The tidal wave of articles announcing the disappearance of pesticides in private gardens by 2019 has opportunely covered two rather inconvenient conceptual pitfalls. The first one, developed in the organic pesticides survey published in Que Choisir [a French review and association of consumers], is that organic pesticides, which will remain allowed, are not really free of inconvenient. Furthermore, these organic pesticides don't eliminate the use of conventional pesticides. In the case of pyrethrin, they outsource it in East Africa and Papua New Guinea.

Pyrethrins are insecticides produced from Dalmatian pyrethrum and chrysanthemums flowers. They are found in dozens of preparations, authorized in organic farming.

The flowers in question, of course, must be grown somewhere. In this case, Tanzania (60% of world production), Papua New Guinea and Kenya. We learn from this Kenyan document that it takes 52,000 plants to obtain 25kg of powder. Here, it is discovered that pyrethrum, unsurprisingly, is attacked by pests and fungi.

And in this very detailed Australian study (1), the perceptive reader finds confirmation of what common sense may already have suggested. To spray these non-food crops, Tanzanians and New Guineans growers have no reason to use organic, more expensive pesticides. They use the conventional arsenal.

"In pyrethrum crops in East Africa and Papua New Guinea," the Australian and American researchers wrote, "fungicides effective against chrysanthemum ascochytosis include ethylene bis-dithiocarbamates, captan, benomyl, chlorothalonil and dichloronaphthoquinone". Moreover, "a range of other products belonging to the group of demethylation inhibitors, including difenoconazole, have proved their efficacy", provided that they have "several applications of these fungicides".

Difenoconazole is almost all that is prohibited by organic agriculture: toxic to mammals, to aquatic environments, and persisting with a half-life of 1600 days under certain conditions. It is page 5 of the study (1).

In the two years after the efficacy tests, researchers praise, "90% of the pyrethrum producers in Tanzania" have adopted the fungicide program. The Australian authors are from the University of Tasmania, where pyrethrum is also grown. One might think they have good information about Africa. MGK, the Australian sector leader, has farms in Tanzania.

In 2010, German researchers pointed out the paradox. Kenya produces dried pyrethrum flowers, but "95% of the raw pyrethrin is exported to more environmentally-conscious developed countries, where it is sold at premium prices, leaving Kenya to import cheaper synthetic pesticides." (2).

The Kenyan case suggests that the cultivation of pyrethrum is not an easy task. From 70% of the world market in the early 2000s, its production fell to less than 5% ten years later, due to irregularities in yields. Agriculture is an exciting but difficult trade.

Erwan Seznec

1) Diseases of Pyrethrum in Tasmania: Challenges and Prospects for Management.  

2) « Incidentally, Kenya is the leading producer of a natural pesticide, pyrethrin, which is a broad-spectrum insecticide made from dried flowers of pyrethrum (Chrysanthemum cinerariaefolium). However, 95% of the crude pyrethrin is exported to more environmentally conscious developed countries, where it earns a premium price, leaving Kenya to import the cheaper toxic synthetic pesticides ».  Potential environmental impacts of pesticides use in the vegetable sub-sector in Kenya. »

I will add, because it seems important to me, that the Australian document also explains, on page 2, that for a successful pyrethrum crop, the use of herbicides is necessary, as well as intensive sprinkler irrigation with use of fertilizers. It is finally learned that the harvest of flowers is mechanical.
All these criteria are a priori contrary to the philosophy of organic farming.

My surprise was such that I decided to look a little more. And I came across a Kenyan document from HighChem Agriculture, a consulting and support company for pyrethrum producers, also selling seeds and crops. This document explains main stages of cultivation ( and shows that pest control is based on 3 synthetic insecticides, carbaryl (a carbamate banned in Europe since 2006), dioxathion (an organophosphorus banned in Europe since 2002) and, surprisingly, alphacypermethrin, a synthetic pyrethroid.
And all this to produce a natural pyrethrin, authorized in organic farming?

Her we are.
What do we have to think?
What I have already told you several times: organic is above all a juicy market, for which everything is allowed, especially cheating cheerfully the consumer, but also the farmer (who in this case buys natural pyrethrins in good faith, without knowing that he is fooled).
This market is primarily developed in the richest countries (especially in Europe), in which it is fashionable, it is even the most perfect chic to consume organic. It's better for the planet!
Yes, except that, on the one hand, the organic has many dark sides that are systematically ignored, and on the other hand, making organic in Europe is much easier if we the most negative aspects are relocated to the other side of the planet!

We are once again in marketing, in communication.
We ignore all non-seller aspects, not to shock the consumer. It is the same problem with GMOs. It is hardly produced in Europe, but it is imported by whole boats produced in other parts of the world.

It's the same thing. Contrary to what I believed, candid and naive, organic pesticides are not produced according to the essential criteria of organic farming.

It's simply unbelievable!!!

This does not detract from the merit of farmers who produce organic, whether by philosophical or economic choice. But they have to do it with a limited number of alternatives to solve phytosanitary problems, that they will have anyway, and which requires them to work extremely precisely because they have very little margin for error.

But it just shows that, ultimately, organic farming is a huge fraud, which is used to the benefit of a few people, on the back of farmers and consumers.

I have already told you, I repeat it once again, and it won't be the last time, the future is not Organic Farming, it is Integrated Farming (, or more recently Agroecology. In short, the use of pesticides is essential for sustainable agriculture, and a fairer and more ecological food production.

Will our politicians be smart, well-advised, honest and courageous to tell to environmental lobbies, as well as to industrial lobbies, that their place is not in the political debate?

20 commentaires:

  1. This is a very nice post . I have visited the site many times and learn about Synthetic Thatch very nicely.

    We are the Largest Supplier of No. 1 Quality Synthetic Thatch Roofing Material and Artificial Bamboo products supplying top-quality Synthetic thatch & Artificial Bamboo products with 20 Year Warranty, UV-proof, Class A flame-retardant, Maintenance-free. You’ll be astonished at how well our Synthetic Thatch Roofings withstand ocean breeze, heavy rain, snow storm, intense sunlight and general wear & tear for more than 20 years while still looking amazing.

  2. As much as your thinking is praised, it is very important to have a beautiful thinking to write a beautiful post and indeed such a beautiful post is rarely seen as much as the beautiful post you have written, it is a very beautiful of my life This is the post I saw today.
    Gurugram escort service
    call girls gurugram
    Gurugram escorts service
    gurugram call girl

  3. As much as your thinking is praised, it is very important to have a beautiful thinking to write a beautiful post and indeed such a beautiful post is rarely seen as much as the beautiful post you have written, it is a very beautiful of my life The post is what I saw today.
    VIP Girls
    escort service gurugram

    call girl gurugram
    Gurugram escorts

  4. Organic vegetable and fruit-

  5. Your post is very cool, and this post is different and beautiful, and it helps us very much. Thank you for sharing this amazing knowledge. But also check our website
    Call Girls DLF Phase 5
    Call Girls Dwarka Delhi
    Call Girls In Bhiwadi
    Gurugram Call Girls Photos
    Call Girls Rewari
    Surajkund Escorts Service
    Call Girls Manesar
    Neemrana Escorts Service

  6. Nice Article! FFor more details about Online Organic Food Product follow given link.

  7. Bonjour,

    Je suis le directeur de l'administration des prêts de NOMARK LOAN FIRM. Nous sommes une société d'investissement financier à la recherche de sociétés avec des projets rentables ou des équipes entrepreneuriales qui ont besoin de capital d'amorçage pour leur entreprise et qui peuvent générer un bon retour sur investissement pendant la durée du financement. Nous nous concentrons sur le soutien aux entreprises à un stade précoce ou tardif.Si vous avez besoin de tout type de prêt, veuillez nous contacter pour tout type de prêt que vous souhaitez, nous proposons des prêts allant de 10000,00 USD à 5000000 USD avec un taux d'intérêt de 2%.
    Contactez-nous avec vos coordonnées par e-mail:

    Si vous êtes intéressé, veuillez nous contacter pour plus de détails et procédures en répondant à cet e-mail:

  8. Great Post! You've provided some great information and ideas to your readers. Please keep sharing.

    Please visit Reticulation Supplies

  9. When I am alone, I come to see your comments. It is a very good comment, how strange is your loneliness in this city, there are thousands of people but no one is like that. One is changed because you are not there, yesterday even the sunlight did not come on the wall. Thank you from my heart
    Hostel Girl Gurugram
    Gurugram vip Girl
    Gurugram party Girls
    Gurgaon Dateing girl
    Naughty Girl Gurugram
    Real Photos Girls Gurugram
    Gurugram Girls Number

  10. Nimbark Organics produces top-notch, 100% certified, genuine organic food to support people in leading happier, healthier, and more wholesome lives. Organic farming products All our Organic Farming Products undergo multiple rounds of quality testing at our processing unit which in return retains the nutritional value of the products.

  11. Compared to conventional foods, including organic food in your diet has a number of nutritional benefitsOrganic Farming Products a number of quality checks at our processing facility which insures high nutritional content, great taste and flavour

  12. We at Nimbark are committed to providing our consumers with organic agricultural products Organic Farming To meet and beyond the requirements for organic produce, our team takes a number of activities.

  13. Nimbark Organic Company is India's Leading Brand for Organic Food and was founded on the tenets of health, ecology, and care Nimbark Organic We have established ourselves as a leading online seller of organic food across the country in the modern, technologically evolved culture.

  14. The Nimbark Organic Company was established on the principles of health, environment, and care Nimbark Organic It is India's leading brand for organic food. We have made a name for ourselves as the nation's top online retailer of organic food in today's technologically advanced society.

  15. Thanks for sharing such a useful article.

    AMMC is a pioneering smart farming company in KSA, using cutting-edge technology to revolutionize agricultural practices. Buy seeds in KSA to maximise the quality and sustainability the agricultural produce. Our innovative solutions empower farmers with real-time data analysis, precision nutrient management, and intelligent farming systems to optimize resource allocation, reduce environmental impact, and enhance productivity.

    Buy seeds in KSA

  16. Nimbark Organic, offered by Nimbark Food, is a premium range of organic products. With a commitment to sustainability, they provide wholesomenimbark organicthey provide wholesome, chemical-free food options. Nimbark Organic ensures the highest quality ingredients, promoting health and well-being.

  17. Nimbark Organic by Nimbark Foods - your pathway to wholesome goodness! Savor the finest selection of organic foods, sourced responsibly from nature's bounty.nimbark organic Embrace a healthier lifestyle with our range of chemical-free

  18. Your blog has quickly become one of our favorites. Your passion for the topics you cover is evident, and it's inspiring to be a part of your online community. Thank you for sharing your expertise!
    Agrisetu is bridging the gap between agriculture-based information databases to small marginal farmers by creating both forward and backward market linkages.
    Best government apps for farmers